This annotated
bibliography focuses on the current media coverage of the Allison Baden Clay
murder, focussing mainly on her funeral, and how her husband has been portrayed
in the light of the media. Each source
that has been analysed presents a slightly different portrayal of Allison Baden
Clays husband, Gerard Baden Clay. The
media coverage of the funeral was all quite similar, which shows that journalists
were working off the same press release.
In a tragic event such as this, this is a good thing, as it means there
were minimal media outlets at the funeral.
The academic text that is used in this annotated bibliography discusses
how trauma can be enhanced on the community and family members when mass
amounts of media outlets appear not only to cover the funeral, but the entire
story in general. A journalist’s job is
to be the eyes and ears of the community, without increasing the trauma of a
family and community further (Kay, Reilly, Connolly, & Cohen, 2010).
Kay,
L., Reilly, R.C., Connolly, K., & Cohen, S. (2010) Help or Harm? Symbolic Violence, secondary trauma and the
impact of press coverage on a community.
Journalism Practice, 4:4, pp. 421-438. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17512780903429829
The authors of
this article discuss the secondary trauma and symbolic violence that can result
from the news coverage of a traumatic event (Kay, Reilly, Connolly, &
Cohen, 2010, p. 421). The main author, Linda
Kay is the Chair and Associate Professor of the Department of Journalism at
Concordia University. Her extensive
knowledge about journalism makes the content of this article exceptionally
credible. Kay and the Concordia
University Community Resilience Research Team carried out extensive research on
the way that press coverage of a traumatic event in a community can affect the
victims, community members, and the community itself (Kay, Reilly, Connolly,
& Cohen, 2010, p. 422). They carried
out this research in a small community in Quebec. The town of only 2000 people experienced a
traumatic event in 2005 where a sixteen year old girl was abducted and
murdered. Throughout the disappearance,
funeral, and ongoing murder investigations, the town was inundated with media
outlets and journalists. Each journalist
was fighting for interviews with residents, and for the latest news regarding
the disappearance (Kay, Reilly, Connolly, & Cohen, 2010, p. 423). The results of the research conducted proved
that five key themes are evident in relation to the impact news coverage can
have on a community. The five themes
are: alienation from the community, anger at the media’s public construction of
the media, intrusion on community life, intrusion on the private process of grief,
and triggering renewed feelings of loss and grief. Kay stresses how important it is for
journalists to report these highly traumatic events with sensitivity and
empathy. Kay believes the mandate for
traumatic events is clear: get the story and get it fast (Kay, Reilly,
Connolly, & Cohen, 2010, pp. 422- 425).
Dalton,
T. (2012, May 12). Posies, a boxful of tissues and tears for the mum gone. The
Courier Mail, pp. 4-6.
A traumatic event
that has recently affected the community of Brookfield is the murder of much
loved and respected mother, Allison Baden-Clay.
The Courier Mails news article, written by Trent Dalton, covered the
funeral of Allison Baden-Clay. The
content in Dalton’s article can be considered highly credible as Dalton has a
well respected reputation throughout Australia, being considered one of
Australia’s best feature journalists. The
article was written with respect to the late mother and wife, it did not draw
upon any of the gossip or suspicion surrounding the murder investigation, unlike
the news clip by Nine News. The article
focussed upon on the emotions of her daughters, husband, and other family
members at the funeral. It portrayed her
family as being incredibly upset throughout the duration of the funeral. The article also reflected upon the great respect
Allison had from loved ones, and her community (Dalton, 2012, pp. 4-6). In comparison to the other news articles that
have been analysed, this article is definitely the most thoughtful and displays
the most respect towards Allison’s family. Compared to the news clip about Gerard Baden Clays
affair, this article would not bring further trauma to the family who are trying to
grieve, especially to the young girls. Dalton
reported the traumatic event like a good journalist should, with sensitivity
and respect to Allison’s family, and the Brookfield community.
Ten News’ short
broadcast of Allison Baden-Clays funeral focussed more on the murder
investigation, rather than the funeral itself.
The news clip restates what Allison’s sister, Vanessa Flower, pledged at
the funeral: “We will bring you to justice, and put the pieces of the puzzle
together to answer the many questions that remain unanswered.” (Beveridge,
2012) The news clip then restates the
facts of Allison’s disappearance and the discovery of her body. The footage used in this news clip focussed
mainly upon Gerard Baden Clay, showing him crying outside the church (Beveridge,
2012). Ten News broadcasts news
throughout Australia on a daily basis, it is nationally recognised as one of
Australia’s most prominent sources of news, it is therefore considered a
credible source. Compared to Courier
Mail’s newspaper article, this was a very concise story, where as the courier
mail talked a lot about the emotions of the family. The information about the funeral that was included
in the news clip was the same information used in Dalton’s newspaper article,
which shows that all the media outlets would have used the same press release
to cover this story.
Nine News’ crime reporter
Alyshia Gates spoke live on May 12, announcing that there had been another
twist in the Allison Baden Clay murder investigation. The new twist regarding the murder
investigation is the confirmation that Gerard Baden Clay was having an affair
with former co worker, Toni McHugh. At
the beginning of the report Gates states that: “Nine News understands Allison’s
husband, Gerard had been having several affairs which are now the subject of
the police investigation.” Gates put
emphasis on ‘several affairs’ in the report, despite the fact that only one
affair has been officially confirmed.
Gates then continues to say that Toni McHugh is one of several people the
police have spoken, to including Gerard Baden Clay. Gates once again puts emphasis on the fact
that Gerard Baden Clay has been interviewed by police (Gates, 2012). The academic article by Linda Kay discusses
how damaging it is for the affected families when the media reports on gossip
surrounding a murder investigation (Kay, Reilly, Connolly, & Cohen, 2010,
p. 421). This murder investigation has
been the subject of a lot of gossip throughout Brisbane, and reports like this
do not help in controlling this gossip. Although
Nine News is considered a reputable media outlet in Australia, this news clip
says that Gerard Baden Clay has had several affairs, when only one has been
confirmed. Unlike the article by The
Courier Mail, which reflects positively on Allison’s life, news clips such as
this one would increase trauma in Allison Baden Clays family, who are trying to
deal with grief.